The folks at Flavorwire have an ingenious recurring column in which they create musical mixtapes for assorted literary characters. Each inspired post is dedicated to one literary character and provides a playlist of music they might have listened to. An exercise like this is catnip for a queer book geek. The column got me thinking, “What music would fill the lives of some of my favorite LGBTQ characters? What music would Myra Breckenridge listen to before teaching an acting class or what song would Celie, from the Color Purple, be humming at her pant’s shop?” 

I knew I had to start with a particular favorite of mine: Andrew Holleran’s classic, hilarious and haunting disco era novel Dancer from the Dance. The novel follows erstwhile romantic Malone on his search for love and meaning amid the debauched 1970s New York City party scene.

Dancer from the Dance , which contains multiple passages describing the euphoria of the early 1970s discos and parties, surprisingly contains very few musical references. The novel provides a vivid sense of time and place, but there are very few passages that describe the actual music of the era.

One disco that is prominently featured in Holleran’s novel, the Twelfth Floor, is based on an early 1970s private club called the 1oth Floor. The website Disco-Disco states:

The 10th Floor crowd was a very glamorous, beautiful and chic white gay crowd, it was the crowd who frequented Fire Island as well as the Flamingo. The club was located on the tenth floor and was a private disco with 400 members, members could bring two guests. Membership was $75. It was a loft space, white, not very large, windows on the front with seating, chairs and sofas, directly across was the dance floor and the DJ booth, it was an intimate space. The elevator often didn’t work so the guests had to walk up 10 flights.

The club was located across the street of the legendary Everard (nicknamed Everhard) Baths…

The 1oth Floor played a very specific type of disco–the early stuff–before disco became infected with overtly euro and pop influences (see Donna Summers). The Tenth Floor played mostly bare bones and raw soul/dance music. The tracks spun at the club were more of the underground funk inspired variety–not so much of the four-to-floor cuts we commonly associate with the scene. Knowing that, it is easy to come up with a hip shaking track-list that would send Malone into disco nirvana.


This Patty Jo track is one of the only songs that Holleran flat-out references in the novel and it’s a Curtis Mayfield produced foot-stomper.

In this classic cut Teddy Pendergrass breaks off a little old school disco philosophy. “Hey Malone, listen to Teddy! You can’t hide from yourself!”

In which Eddie Kendricks tries to prove his feminist bonafides while still trying to get laid. The characters in Dancer from the Dance were notoriously apolitical; maybe they just needed a political manifesto with a beat?

If the Temptations are telling you there are natural laws in the world then it must be true. No relative queer theory on the dance floor!

Minnie! ‘Nuff said!

There is always the come down–that moment when you come home from the club alone and a little dejected. You need a wistful track to help you rest up before you head out and hit the scene all over again.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

10 Responses to “Literary Mixtape: ‘Dancer from the Dance’–Malone’s Imaginary Disco Set”

  1. 19 January 2012 at 11:03 AM #

    Awesome concept to appropriate and excellent choices.

    I’d have to add Evelyn ‘Champagne’ King’s defiant ‘Shame’ because it nicely compliments Malone’s yearningly romantic sensibility.

    • 19 January 2012 at 11:12 AM #

      Yes! Shame is a good one. The thing I loved about disco is that it gave us so many sad songs that you could you dance to….killing two birds with one stone as it were : you could be euphoric and heartbroken at the same time.

  2. 19 January 2012 at 7:19 PM #

    William, this is fantastic execution.

    I need to check my collection, but my only reference for loft music is “David Mancuso Presents the Loft.”

    I like yours because it’s so specifically linked to bringing the text, era, & feelings to life.

    now, if you could find a way of raising Sutherland from the dead …

    • 19 January 2012 at 7:32 PM #

      Tomas! I don’t think the world(or Chelsea for that matter) could handle a Zombie Sutherland.

      • 19 January 2012 at 9:56 PM #

        yes, since the sight of a drippy swamp thing blithely mincing down eighth avenue, unawares beneath his wide brimmed straw hat & thrumming fan would probably cause mass havoc amongst the queens exiting DB on 23rd & 7th ave. Alternatively, I would be v. interested in any YouTube seance (set in New Orleans) calling forth Sutherland & Truman Capote

  3. 20 January 2012 at 9:00 AM #

    I love this post. Thanks so much for reminding me of one of my favorite works of literature and sharing some funked up dance music as I woke up this morning!

  4. 26 January 2012 at 2:42 PM #

    Thanks for this post! Having just read the book for the first, it’s fresh in my mind. He does mention Giving Up by Zumela in the novel.

  5. 6 March 2012 at 2:27 PM #

    Other songs mentioned in the book:
    “Love’s Theme”, Love Unlimited Orchestra; “I’ll Always Love My Mama”, The Intruders; “Giving Up”, Glaays Knight & The Pips.

  6. 15 May 2015 at 3:25 PM #

    Dear William Johnson: I am currently in the middle of Andrew Holleran’s “Dancer from the Dance.” Thank you for filling me in on some of the real life history and music that went into the novel. The Wild & Wooly Seventies had already ended and AIDS was already on the scene when I was ready to come out. It was a time and place that I missed, rather to my frustration.

  7. 16 September 2016 at 3:50 PM #

    I arrived in NYC in Sept.1976, had my first man-on-man encounter with a male hustler while trolling around Times Square, who convinced me to follow his footsteps onto the the stage of the Gaiety Male Burlesque. That cache got my 18 yr.old hick from upstate ass into the best underground clubs in NYC: the Gallery, Flamingo, 12West, the Anvil, Crisco Disco, Hurrah, Studio54, IcePalace57, Paradise Garage, the Saint, Sound Factory, the World,… which I wrote about in ‘Homo GoGo Man: a fairytale about a boy who grew up in discoland.’ (Amazon,DonnaInk,BarnesandNoble)

Leave a Reply

Please fill the required box or you can’t comment at all. Please use kind words. Your e-mail address will not be published.

Gravatar is supported.

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>