Did you know that you could write to Jeff Bezos?

You can. His email is online.

Customers write to him, and supposedly, he forwards them on to his team to respond.

Why is this relevant? Well, back in January of this year, I wrote to Jeff Bezos. I didn’t think anything would happen, since, you know, Amazon CEO, probably gets thousands of emails a day, but I have now learned I was wrong.

My story starts with an email—from Amazon, alerting me to new titles in romance. Since I do buy romance books, I opened it, and saw that it was listing only straight romances. This was strange to me since 99% of the hundreds of books I’ve bought over the last couple years from Amazon are LGBTQ romance books.

At the bottom of this all-straight romance email, there was a link that said, “See more” and I clicked on that, thinking, “Well, maybe what I actually buy is here.” That took me to the main Romance storefront of the Kindle store, featuring Nora Roberts (and her pseudonym J.D. Robb), regency, supernatural romances…and all were straight. And on the left of the page, there was a listing of almost 20 categories, from African American romance to gothic to mysteries to vampires to…time travel, but no listing for LGBTQ romance.

I scoured Amazon’s site to find a customer service email to complain to, and shot off a note to what I will now call, “The Ether.”

The Ether did not respond.

Sometime later, I complained to a friend in a bar about this issue and my email to The Ether, and she said, “Why don’t you write to Jeff Bezos? You can do that.”

“Really?” That suggestion seemed completely unbelievable.

But two beers will make any idea sound like a good one, so I went home that night, grabbed the email that I had sent to The Ether, added to the top “Dear Mr. Bezos”, found Jeff Bezos’ email online, and hit send.

That was Wednesday, January 22. Less than two days later, on Friday morning, I get an email from Anthony at Amazon’s Executive Customer Relations (ECR) telling me that, “Jeff Bezos received your email and asked me to respond on his behalf.”

Anthony said they’re looking into the issue, but in the meantime, did I know that there was a Gay and Lesbian section at Amazon, and that I could look there for the books that I want?

I was a little miffed here at Anthony. I think anyone who buys LGBTQ books at Amazon knows about that category, but that doesn’t solve the issue of having LGBTQ romance books excluded from the main Romance storefront, even though thousands of these books are tagged as connected to that store. (You can see all the tags at the bottom of each book page.) They’re just invisible from the main storefront, so the only way to find them is to go in through the Gay & Lesbian door or do a search on a title or author.

I started writing an angry response to Anthony, and while doing so, went to the main Romance storefront to get the link to paste into the email. When I got there, I stopped for a second, and I looked at it.

And I looked again.

It had already been changed.

Right there, in that list of categories on the side, was Gay Romance and Lesbian Romance. Right there with the Gothic and the Inspirational and the Multicultural and the Time Travel.

But what was most striking were the numbers.

Next to each category in parentheses there are numbers that tell you how many books are in that category. At that time, there were over 60,000 contempories, 20,000 mysteries, 5,000 “New Adult”, 15,000 Fantasy titles, and over 2,000 Time Travel romances.

On that day, there were over 11,000 Gay and Lesbian romance books.

That was the most striking thing. Not just that the change had been made, or made so quickly, but there were numbers showing how many thousands of books had been living in that store, hidden from the main page. Until that day.

I scrapped the beginnings of my angry response to Anthony and wrote a new note, and cc-ed Jeff Bezos, and thanked them for making the change. “I’ve always appreciated Amazon’s stance on taking the ‘long view’ on strategy, products, and customer service. Thank you for taking the long view on including gay and lesbian romance titles in the main romance section.”

Empowering Action and Promoting Visibility

This story isn’t about Amazon making that change, although I’m glad that they did since eight months later, you can see the Gay and Lesbian romance categories growing to almost 14,000 books.

It’s about knowing that even with so many advancements happening around us for LGBTQ media, that we’re still at a point where we need to ask (and demand) for change to happen. The Status Quo may not see the thousands of invisible books, but we see them, and we still have to ask for them to be visible.

GRNW_LogoWe’ve learned this lesson beyond this letter to Jeff Bezos as well. Since the summer of 2013, we have been striving in Seattle to increase exposure to LGBTQ romance books by hosting free public reading events, reader meet-ups, community book drives, and a conference, the Gay Romance Northwest Meet-Up, the only conference in the Pacific Northwest that celebrates LGBTQ romance fiction.

Since we started a little over a year ago, we’ve hosted nine public readings—at the University Book Store, at the Seattle nonprofit Gay City, and at the Seattle Public Library, showcasing more than 20 LGBTQ fiction writers. We have hosted seven reader meet-ups in Seattle and Portland, gathering queer romance readers and writers from around the region together. We have hosted two book drives, one for the Gay City LGBT Library and one for the LGBT youth services organization Lambert House, and amassed close to 400 LGBTQ books for their collections. We hosted our first conference in September 2013 at the Seattle Public Library that had over 120 attendees, and we’re gathering this September 20 for the second conference, with over 50 LGBTQ romance authors attending, and estimating over 200 attendees.

What I’ve learned from these efforts, like that letter to Jeff Bezos, is that all of these activities have started because we asked for them. We asked the library and the book store to host us. We asked donors for the books for the book drives. We asked the readers and writers to come join us and come meet each other. We asked community partners like Lambda Literary, Pride Foundation, Hedgebrook, and Gay City to partner with us and be a part of this initiative.

I have met resistance. To celebrating LGBTQ romance, or celebrating romance in general. (I’ve had more than one literary group tells us that they can’t be seen associating with our activities because we do something as lowly as “genre fiction.”) I’ve had local chapters of the Romance Writers of American (RWA) tell us they will work with us, and I’ve had other local RWA chapters refuse to be seen with us. I’ve had bookstores tells us that our readers aren’t “their kind” of customers.

But even with those setbacks, no matter how disappointing or demoralizing they are, we still were able to do as much as we did in a year because we asked for it. Because we, along with these readers, writers, and partners, acknowledge the value of queer romance books, and that they should be celebrated publicly like other books and not hidden.

A Call to Action

Not every ask has been successful. This summer, I wrote once again to Jeff Bezos. This time wondering about why I don’t receive emails recommending LGBTQ books. This spring I bought one straight romance book—written by my stepmother—and soon after I received an email from Amazon recommending me other straight romance books to buy.

I’ve bought hundreds of LGBTQ romance books in the last two years, and I have never received an email notifying me of other LGBTQ romance books.

Since 2012, I’ve purchased 37 books by gay mystery author Josh Lanyon, and not once have I ever received an email notifying me about books similar in theme to Lanyon’s. But I buy one Richard Castle book on sale, and soon after, I receive the “You might like these other mysteries…” email. (None of which highlight LGBTQ main characters.)

I’m sure there isn’t a policy in place that prevents Amazon from notifying customers who buy LGBTQ books about other LGBTQ books they could buy.

There isn’t one…is there?

All I know is, after giving Amazon all my customer data which very clearly states what I regularly buy, and receiving emails about what I don’t buy, these emails are like a strange, underlying message from Amazon telling me what I should buy, and who I should be. (And not recognize who I am.)

I asked back in July if they could look into this discrepancy, and imagine—imagine—what customers would buy if they were actually targeted with what they normally purchase?

Once again, Anthony from Amazon’s ECR replied, and said they were looking into it.

Unlike back in January, there has been no change yet, or at least no targeted emails saying “It looks like you buy LGBTQ books. Would you like to see more?”

If you read a lot of queer genre fiction, and if it bothers you that you don’t receive notifications about similar products, feel free to join me in writing to Jeff Bezos about it.

We can do that. His email is online.

There are still changes that can be made.

Tags: , , , , , ,

12 Responses to ““Dear Mr. Bezos”: Pushing Queer Romance Forward With Community Action”

  1. 16 September 2014 at 2:06 PM #

    Another, possibly related, phenomenon I’ve noticed (at least related to my own book) is that the “customers also bought” display for GLBT books seems oddly restricted to other GLBT books. I know from personal report of people who have bought my lesbian historic fantasy through Amazon who are primarily SFF readers, but somehow their other purchases don’t get displayed there. (And I’d be willing to bet that my book doesn’t get displayed for their non-GLBT purchases.) The system seems designed to silo GLBT books off into — dare I say — a closet.

    • 19 September 2014 at 12:16 PM #

      I have noticed the exact same thing.

    • 22 September 2014 at 1:26 PM #

      In the interests of accuracy and fairness, I want to update my previous comments. Amazon is currently showing “people who bought ‘Daughter of Mystery’ also bought Sherman Alexie’s ‘Reservation Blues'” *and* vice versa on the page for ‘Reservation Blues’. (This phenomenon is entirely due to both being required reading for a particular college English class — I have insider information on this fact.) But since it contradicts my previous implication that there might be a deliberate exclusion happening, I felt it was important to post the new information.

  2. 17 September 2014 at 1:15 PM #

    Not so long ago, I searched for my books at Amazon and B&N using “lesbian science fiction romance,” and several rearrangements of words, as part of a blog post. There were 11 pages of gay male and hetero science fiction and not sf books listed before I hit the first lesbian title. Not mine ; P I think things are better now, thanks to folks writing in and the efforts of the RRW chapter. Straightening out the categories (sorry, but you know what I mean ;) is paramount. If readers don’t think their supplier has what they want to read, everyone loses.

    Thanks for writing to Mr. Bezos!

  3. 19 September 2014 at 11:46 AM #

    I’m not sure why the existence of this category – or of “over 11,000 Gay and Lesbian romance books” – should be considered a victory for anyone.

    In the first place, these 11,000 books are overwhelmingly self-published – and it shows.

    In the second, it remains impossible to search Amazon for LGBT literary fiction without having to wade through thousands of titles – most of them with covers that are NSFW – in the categories of erotica, beach-reading, potboilers, Gay Paranormal Werewolf Erotic Romance Stories, or Gay Transgender Holiday Romance Novelettes (I am not making this up).

    As of five minutes ago, for example, the FIRST THREE BOOKS in the “Gay & Lesbian Literature and Fiction” section are: Flings: Sexy One Night Only Encounters, Gym Boys: Gay Erotic Stories, and Me and My Boi: Queer Erotic Stories.

    Good for these writers and the writers of 11,000 jersey-and bodice-rippers. I have no objection to the existence of their books or to their presence on Amazon.

    But I do object to their being indiscriminately classified in the same category as David Leavitt, EM Forster, May Sarton, Colm Toibin, and Thom Gunn.

    The reality is that Amazon has a long way to go before it creates a search function that actually allows readers to find non-genre fiction, which currently overwhelms, not so say drowns, all other LGBTQ writing.

    And our publishing industry – which now includes basements and spare rooms across the continent – has a lot to answer for in the long agony of serious queer fiction.

    • 19 September 2014 at 12:09 PM #

      I’m so glad that you’re not making up the existence of Gay Transgender Holiday Romance Novelettes. Because that sounds totally awesome! I hope there are ones for every holiday, because- AWESOME.

  4. […] a 16 September 2014 post on the Lambda Literary site, “Dear Mr. Bezos”: Pushing Queer Romance Forward With Community Action,” Tracy Timmons-Gray congratulates herself for a letter-writing campaign—to Amazon’s Jeff […]

  5. 19 September 2014 at 2:30 PM #

    I wasn’t going to comment on this, after reading it first thing this morning, but it’s still bugging me, five hours later. I know it shouldn’t. I should just register a thought and move on. And yet…

    Is this what’s it’s come to, then? Is this the acme of a civil rights movement decades in the making: the equal opportunity to be tracked and marketed to by the algorithm of a culturally destructive corporation? Someone notify Act-up!

    If the most horrifying case of homophobia that one can find to which to commit an essayistic call-to-arms is that Amazon has heterocentrically overlooked an opportunity to spam the niche market of a niche market of a niche market, then perhaps it’s time to steer one’s attention to other areas of more urgent social injustice.

  6. 19 September 2014 at 3:09 PM #

    It’s crazy how influential Amazon is to the sales of indie authors, which so many queer romance authors are, but we’re so in the dark about how they operate. The algorithms that decide whether or not a book get recommended can make all the difference in a novel’s success, but sometimes they seem to be completely random. :/
    Anyway, it’s really exciting to be part of a growing genre, and I really appreciate the work you’re doing to get it out there! I’ve heard so many stories from lgbt readers and writers who had a eureka moment when they discovered that queer romance was a genre that existed. It’s so great to be able to see people like ourselves falling in love, having adventures, and just generally present in genre fiction that we’ve so long been excluded from.
    As a side note, I’m super bummed out that I won’t be able to make it to GRNW and am going to make every effort to be there next year! It seems to good to pass up again.

  7. […] to action, or more simply, a call to “asking”. As we discussed in our conference remarks and in Lambda Literary recently, so much of what we’ve accomplished this year has been because we asked or advocated for […]

  8. […] we wrote recently in Lambda Literary, we’re still at the point in the queer romance genre evolution that we have to ask for […]

  9. […] she loves reading genre fiction, drawing cartoony monsters, singing karaoke, sending Jeff Bezo irritating letters, talking incessantly about community action and romance fiction, and avoiding her cat when he […]

Leave a Reply

Please fill the required box or you can’t comment at all. Please use kind words. Your e-mail address will not be published.

Gravatar is supported.

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>